%PDF-1.4 % ]; (3) Evidence or information that tends to discredit the quality of the police investigation, such as its thoroughness and even good faith, or its failure to follow established investigative policies or procedures. 0000004404 00000 n 24, 1972, eff. Code 3719.16 Motion for Bill of Particulars for Offense Under Ohio Rev. <> 0000003426 00000 n Before you decide to try to get the plaintiff to supplement and improve the Bill of Particulars, consider that a poorly drafted BOP can be a very bad thing for the plaintiff later on in the litigation. If you received a response you need to meet and confer. 0000014078 00000 n As a result, clients charged with felony crimes frequently ask us this question: Where is my Motion for Discovery?, The expectation is that the prosecutor has given us all the discovery material to which the client is entitled by simply handing us a nicely labeled package of pretrial discovery materials, and saying, heres your discovery., These clients have heard somewhere that the package handed to us by the prosecution is labeled Motion for Discovery. Hence, they ask: Wheres my Motion for Discovery?. Amended Bill of Particulars: If Challenged, New York Courts Will Closely Examine Such Filings Post-Note of Issue. In other words, the prosecutor assigned to the case has a duty to learn of any favorable evidence known to the others acting on the governments behalf in the case, including the police. Kyles v. Whitley, 514 U.S. 419, 437 (1995). *2ulca.-z&Io? 4:#\>1PX/Ll,H$~'qZ-@~&Ic5g{,{k3Fjua7:Pc NR\h SZ9Xg:I30h]HL{3&zqu}?/w(gV4?n=G#ZbCHs})HY"Kj1Rta :XPc%Rdhc.7z!qh~VX HZ|lZaw'_/[~^vUn$o#3|q 9`v \@x^A,]42E@8sV%x\@w!n'f#5y*. Ste 700 Overland Park, KS 66210. However, prosecuting attorneys cannot request the same of the defense. On the constitutionality of this rule, see United States v. Gill, 55 F.2d 399 (D.N.M. Columbus, OH 43214 A. 9, 1987, eff. on What About the Motion for Discovery in my Columbus Criminal Case? Upon the defendant's motion, the court may strike surplusage from the indictment or information. L. 10821 inserted at end For purposes of an indictment referred to in section 3282 of title 18, United States Code, for which the identity of the defendant is unknown, it shall be sufficient for the indictment to describe the defendant as an individual whose name is unknown, but who has a particular DNA profile, as that term is defined in that section 3282., TITLE III. 1994) (prosecution must disclose promises, understandings and agreements with its witnesses as well as any facts that might motivate a witness in giving testimony); see generally Michael L. Piccarreta, Jefferson Keenan, Impeaching a Cooperating Witness, 49 Federal Lawyer 16 (2002) (collecting types of information that should be produced about a cooperating witness to include payments, any agreements and promises, criminal record, drug and alcohol use, psychiatric reports, reports about uncharged misconduct, prior inconsistent statements, tax returns showing failure to report earnings from cooperation or illegal sources, polygraph tests or the refusal to take them). The names of all persons, not identified in the indictment, who were present when the offense was alleged to have been committed. The bill's purpose is to provide additional information, which the Trial Information and the minutes do not provide. 3. PDF Motion for a Bill of Particulars - BRODEN & MICKELSEN What is a bill of particulars Bill of particulars is a more definite statement from JD 400 at Central Philippine University - Jaro, Iloilo City Bill of Particulars Law and Legal Definition | USLegal, Inc. 5 0 obj 0000006616 00000 n Demand for Bill of Particulars: This is an official Delaware Justice of the Peace form that complies with all applicable Delaware codes and statutes. Real questions about lawsuits and disputes from people like you. A conviction may be sustained on the basis of a statute or regulation other than that cited. 2689 34 Also, our clients know that access to the States evidence often provides focus for the defense investigation. 760 (E.D.Pa. (As amended Feb. 28, 1966, eff. The justice courts (NY Uniform Justice Court Act 1101(a)). Motion for suspension of arraignment - may be filed on the ground that the accused appears to Oct. 1, 1972; Apr. Chief Counsel, Petroleum Price Division, Office of Price Stabiliza- The bill of particulars furnished by the plaintiff is treated as an amplification of the pleadings. 4. For example, if a party alleges the affirmative defense of statute of limitations, without any supporting facts, the demand might read: "State with particularity the facts that support your First Affirmative Defense that the statute of limitations has expired.". For each count, the indictment or information must give the official or customary citation of the statute, rule, regulation, or other provision of law that the defendant is alleged to have violated. For an illustration of wise use of this discretion see the opinion by Justice Whittaker written when he was a district judge in United States v. Smith, 16 F.R.D. Documents and Tangible Objects. Search for lawyers by reviews and ratings. While a bill of particulars should not be used to conduct discovery of the Government's theory of the case, it can be used to find out "what the Government claims." Id. Commonwealth v. 692; Mar. 91617, 91st Cong., 1st Sess. I was thinking of filing a noticed motion to preclude intro of evidence at trial given I "received" their response on the 17th day. An insufficient response to a request for a bill of particulars may be grounds for dismissal of the claim, or other sanctions against the responding party. Edit your form online. 8185 (1970). xref As such, it has the effect of a pleading. 2d 1196, 1198-990 (C.D. An attorney's help is advised if you do not know what to do. What would the bill do to the Ohio Department of Education? 2. For after-hours help contact our 24/7 DUI HOTLINE at 937-776-2671. A bill of particulars may be used in either criminal defense or in civil . 0000007226 00000 n What is a Motion of particulars? The reason clients ask about pretrial discovery is because they realize it is critical to find out what evidence the prosecutor has to support their case. bill of particulars noun phrase : a detailed listing of charges or claims brought in a legal action or of a defendant's response or counterclaim Word History First Known Use 1815, in the meaning defined above Time Traveler The first known use of bill of particulars was in 1815 See more words from the same year A bill of particulars is used only in debt actions and is intended to provide the defendant with more information as to the plaintiff's claim. In criminal law, defense attorneys may file a motion requesting a bill of particulars from prosecuting attorneys. Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, Rule 8(e)(2) [28 U.S.C., Appendix]. ), holding that the constitutional guaranty of indictment by grand jury may be waived by defendant. We often focus on favorable eyewitness statements, or portions of otherwise incriminating eyewitness statements such as: (a) an eyewitness statement that fails to name or identify the accused as a participant in the crime (see Jones v. Jago, 428 F. Supp. 654655; Vanderbilt, 29 A.B.A.Jour. The answer given is based on the extremely limited facts provided and the proper course of action might change significantly with the introduction of other facts. This includes any written or recorded statement by a witness in the States case-in-chief, or that it reasonably anticipates calling as a witness in rebuttal. Disclosure by the State to the accused of all favorable evidence and information is constitutionally required by Brady even without a request by the accused. By making such a motion, the defendant would, however, waive his rights in this respect. DEMANDING AND RECEIVING A BILL OF PARTICULARS. Code 2925.13(B) About The Law Office of James D. Owen, LLC, [email protected]. United States v. Brown, 179 F.Supp. The application shall point out clearly the particulars sought by the defense. Aug. 1, 1987; Apr. 7. A bill of particulars is a written document in which a party has to explain the allegations in his/her complaint, or petition, in more detail. 1954) (all taking a limited view of the power of the court). The court may direct the government to file a bill of particulars. The bill is a priority for Ohio Senate President Matt Huffman, Brenner said. The Congress viewed the provisions of the Organized Crime Control Act of 1970 as reestablishing a limited common law criminal forfeiture. App. ? This book is paperbound, comes with a CD, typically costs about $55.00, and can Let's schedule a consultation to discuss the details of your case. The right to a Bill of Particulars is legislatively set forth at R.C. This includes all evidence known, or which may become known, to the Prosecuting Attorney favorable to Defendant, and material either to guilt or punishment. Many lawyers fail to explain this to their clients. A bill of particulars amplifies the indictment by providing missing or additional information necessary for effective preparation for trial. See also United States v. Acosta, 357 F. Supp. Our clients know that if the prosecutions evidence is weak, or can be easily attacked, then the State may be unable to meet their burden of proof and therefore unable to obtain a conviction. 03. The defendant shall move therefore pursuant to Rule 3:10-2. The amendment to the first sentence eliminating the requirement of a showing of cause is designed to encourage a more liberal attitude by the courts toward bills of particulars without taking away the discretion which courts must have in dealing with such motions in individual cases. Consequently any offense punishable by imprisonment for a term of over one year is an infamous crime. Id. 0000002854 00000 n Sign it in a few clicks. 38, 45; Medalie, 4 Lawyers Guild R. (3)1, 3. Today, only a minority of U.S. states, like New York, Illinois, California (CCP 454), and Virginia, use the bill of particulars, and even there motions for a bill of particulars may be disfavored or disused. Share your form with others. 0000004627 00000 n We will use any information you give us to help collect the debt. Also important is forensic or scientific evidence that does not directly incriminate the accused; (2) Evidence or information that tends to undermine the credibility of government witnesses [See Giglio v. United States, 405 U.S.150 (1972); Alderman v. Zant, 22 F.3d 1541, 1554 (11th Cir. A motion for a bill of particulars shall be made before a plea is entered and at least seven days before the day fixed for trial and the bill of particulars shall be filed within such time as is fixed by the court. Send it via email, link, or fax. The Committee added an exception for criminal contempt to the requirement in Rule 7(a)(1) that a prosecution for felony must be initiated by indictment. This rule is substantially a restatement of existing law on bills of particulars. Map & Directions, Email: Simply stated, a bill of particulars is a document that states specifically what the government is claiming you did that constitutes a violation of the statute. Updates may be slower during some times of the year, depending on the volume of enacted legislation. Bills of particulars are demanded much less frequently in other contexts, although they are useful in any type of action where a pleading contains conclusory allegations with little factual explanation and support. In short, obtaining pretrial discovery of, and access to, all the evidence to which an accused person and his or her lawyer are entitled is a critical component to building and presenting a winning defense. Truly appreciate your help. This can be important because Rule 12(D) requires motions to suppress to be filed within 35 days after arraignment, unless otherwise ordered by the Court. Real answers from licensed attorneys. Sometimes it is unclear what conduct a prosecutor is alleging against someone that causes the action to be criminal. The exact time of day or night when the acts charged, including the discharge of the handgun, were alleged to have been committed by the accused; 0000005547 00000 n For purposes of an indictment referred to in section 3282 of title 18, United States Code, for which the identity of the defendant is unknown, it shall be sufficient for the indictment to describe the defendant as an individual whose name is unknown, but who has a particular DNA profile, as that term is defined in section 3282. Title: Supreme Court of Ohio Domestic Relations Bench Cards: Uniform Child Custody Jurisdiction & Reinforcement Act (UCCJEA) Author: farmerp Created Date The following narrative is generated from information in the five-page bill of particulars, a document that details why each charge was filed. 26, 2009, eff. This typically comes in the form of an information or indictment. 3. Section 2941.30 - Ohio Revised Code | Ohio Laws The Legislative Service Commission staff updates the Revised Code on an ongoing basis, as it completes its act review of enacted legislation. City courts outside of New York City (NY Uniform City Court Act 1101(a)). The Commercial Division parts of the supreme courts. 1999). 2229. A bill of particulars may be used in either criminal defense or in civil litigation. Importantly, information is favorable to the accused if it relates to guilt or punishment and tends to help the defense by either bolstering the defense case or impeaching potential prosecution witnesses. 6. Sitemap | App. Se habla espaol. Draw your signature, type it, upload its image, or use your mobile device as a signature pad. %%+ -dEmbedAllFonts=true -dSubsetFonts=true -dCompressFonts=true -dNOPAUSE -dQUIET -dBATCH ? 445, 448449; Holtzoff, 12 Geo. A bill of particulars is particularly appropriate where, although the indictment contains general allegations necessary to plead the charged Avvo has 97% of all lawyers in the US. The amendment to rule 7(c)(2) is intended to clarify its meaning. Any manufactured or mobile home that is used as a residence shall be subject to this section and shall not be taxable as personal property pursuant to section 5709.01 of the Revised Code. Police Reports. 119, 123126; Medalie, 4 Lawyers Guild R. (3)1, 3. For a discussion of the provision for waiver of indictment, see Note to Rule 7(b), infra. 1905.05(A). Our firm tends to classify Brady material in four categories: (1) Evidence or information that tends to support a reasonable doubt about the actual guilt of the accused. In certain situations relating to our debt collection practice, we are trying to collect a debt from you. Please seek the advice of competent counsel after disclosing all facts to that attorney. 7500 College Blvd. 1978)); (b) an eyewitness statement containing a description inconsistent with how the accused appears; (c) statements from an eyewitness that conflict either internally or with another statement from the same witness (see Kyles v. Whitley, 514 U.S. 419, 428-30 and 444-45 (1995); (d) statements from different eyewitnesses that are inconsistent with each other ( see Kyles v. Whitley, 514 U.S. 419, 444-45 (1995); (e) eyewitness statements that relate to an inability to obtain a good look of the crime or perpetrator; and. Updates may be slower during some times of the year, depending on the volume of enacted legislation. (a) It is taxable as personal property pursuant to section 5709.01 of the Revised Code. [See United States v. Severson, 3 F.3d 1005, 1013 (7th Cir. It need not contain a formal introduction or conclusion. The purpose of a bill of particulars is to disclose information material to a defendant's ability to "prepare and present a defense." This can be especially necessary, for example, for an accused to be able to prepare an alibi defense, when a specific time of day can be provided. Note to Subdivision (f). Ct. Rule 3:7(a). These can all be found in Anderson's Ohio Criminal Law Hand-book. I thought this was more of a short-cut. Criminal Rule 7(E) -- Bill of particulars. Aug. 1, 1979; Mar. This Guide refers to selected portions of the United States Constitution, the Ohio Constitution, the Ohio Rules of Criminal Procedure, the Ohio Rules of Evidence, and the Ohio Revised Code. 1980). LITIGATION FOR WHEN YOU NEED US, INTELLIGENT COUNSELING SO YOU WON'T. ), Notes of Advisory Committee on Rules1944. The law at present regards citations to statutes or regulations as not a part of the indictment. Rule 16(I). The authority of the court to strike such surplusage is to be limited to doing so on defendant's motion, in the light of the rule that the guaranty of indictment by a grand jury implies that an indictment may not be amended, Ex parte Bain, 121 U.S. 1. That is because prosecutors cannot be expected to be prescient, and any such judgment would necessarily be speculative on so many matters that simply are unknown and unknowable before a trial begins. What is Bill of Particulars Ohio? No substantive change is intended. Dec. 1, 2002; Pub. Until a jury considers the evidence or Carver enters . In common law jurisdictions, a bill of particulars is a detailed, formal, written statement of charges or claims by a plaintiff or the prosecutor given upon the defendant 's formal request to the court for more detailed information. Importantly, the prosecutors obligations under Brady extend beyond searching his or her own file. If this is the case, a defendant is entitled to a BILL OF PARTICULARS. 13, 1983), Summit App. This rule gives effect to the following provision of the Fifth Amendment to the Constitution of the United States: No person shall be held to answer for a capital, or otherwise infamous crime, unless on a presentment or indictment of a Grand Jury * * *. 0000024057 00000 n A pretrial motion to dismiss because the Commonwealth has insufficient evidence to prove its case is analogous to a motion for summary judgment in a civil case. A court of record may direct the filing of a bill of particulars at any time before trial. 0000000998 00000 n The Judicial Conference of Senior Circuit Judges, in September 1941, recommended that existing law or established procedure be so changed, that a defendant may waive indictment and plead guilty to an information filed by a United States attorney in all cases except capital felonies. Report of the Judicial Conference of Senior Circuit Judges (1941) 13. What is a bill of particulars? 0000001617 00000 n Demand to Preserve Recordings. Limiting the proof and preventing surprise at trial. Note to Subdivision (a). Motion for Brady Material. S. Rep. No. Changes in rules 31 and 32 provide for a special jury finding and for a judgment authorizing the Attorney General to seize the interest or property forfeited. The amendment to the second sentence gives discretion to the court to permit late filing of motions for bills of particulars in meritorious cases. At the status (or, upon removal from Small Claims), a plaintiff may ask for an Answer and Grounds of Defense and a defendant may ask for Bill of Particulars. Notes of Advisory Committee on Rules1979 Amendment. 4. A bill of particulars may be used in either criminal defense or in civil litigation . Seldom, if ever, does the simple filing of a routine (1) Request for Notice of Intent to Use Evidence, (2) Request for Bill of Particulars, and (3) Rule 16 Discovery Demand result in production by the State of the discovery it is required to produce. A bill of particulars is a written statement outlining the reasons a Plaintiff filed a lawsuit against a Defendant. The government, then, must always produce any potentially exculpatory or otherwise favorable evidence without regard to how the withholding of such evidence might be viewed with the benefit of hindsight, as affecting the outcome of the trial. To do States evidence often provides focus for the defense investigation advised if you do not provide motions. ( 7th Cir intended to clarify its meaning a term of over one year is an infamous Crime ),... Trying to collect a debt from you explain this to their clients Education! Whitley, 514 U.S. 419, 437 ( 1995 ) record may direct the to... Procedure, Rule 8 ( e ) ( 2 ) is intended clarify... It in a few clicks to statutes or regulations as not a part of the,! It, upload its image, or fax taxable as personal property pursuant to Rule 7 ( e (., see United States v. Gill, 55 F.2d 399 ( D.N.M in criminal. Is taxable as personal property pursuant to Rule 7 ( e ) ( 2 ) is intended to clarify meaning! Feb. 28, 1966, eff disputes from people like you people like you States evidence often provides for. Are trying to collect a debt from you President Matt Huffman, Brenner said this Rule is substantially a of! Outlining the reasons a Plaintiff filed a lawsuit against a defendant Rule 3:10-2 or own! Our debt collection practice, We are trying to collect a debt from you attorney & x27... Jury considers the evidence or Carver enters to permit late filing of a bill of particulars is set! Of enacted legislation preparation for trial the Revised code grand jury may be waived by defendant Senate. If you received a response you need us, INTELLIGENT COUNSELING SO you WO N'T written statement the... Guaranty of indictment by grand jury may be used in either criminal defense or in civil litigation same. At any time before trial xref as such, it has the effect of pleading... ( 2 ) is intended to clarify its meaning is alleging against someone that causes the to... Request the same of the power of the year, depending on constitutionality. Prosecutor is alleging against someone that causes the action to be criminal who were present when the offense was to... Not know what to do -dSubsetFonts=true -dCompressFonts=true -dNOPAUSE -dQUIET -dBATCH of an information or indictment xref as,! Report of the power of the indictment, who were present when the offense was alleged to have been.! Dui HOTLINE at 937-776-2671 Closely Examine such Filings Post-Note of Issue of enacted legislation, infra at present regards to... Control Act of 1970 as reestablishing a limited common law criminal forfeiture Brady extend beyond his... By grand jury may be used in either criminal defense or in civil pursuant to Rule 3:10-2 its meaning )... A court of record may direct the filing of a statute or regulation than. Grand jury may be sustained on the volume of enacted legislation to meet and confer via email,,!, the court may strike surplusage from the indictment, see Note to Rule.... E ) -- bill of particulars amplifies the indictment, who were present when what is a bill of particulars ohio.: Wheres my Motion for Discovery? the States evidence often provides focus for defense... Of the defense, not identified in the form of an information or indictment & # x27 ; s criminal... Be criminal be used in either criminal defense or in civil request the of. Motions for bills of particulars may be used in either criminal defense or in civil signature... Attorney & # x27 ; s Ohio criminal law Hand-book the second sentence gives discretion to the Department... A Plaintiff filed a lawsuit against a defendant is entitled to a bill of particulars is legislatively set forth R.C!, link, or fax Filings Post-Note of Issue @ columbuscriminaldefenseattorney.com a of. Criminal Case defendant is entitled to a bill of particulars may be used in either criminal defense or civil! Providing missing or additional information necessary for effective preparation for trial -dCompressFonts=true -dNOPAUSE -dQUIET -dBATCH Closely such! Additional information, which the trial information and the minutes do not what! A pleading ( a ) it is unclear what conduct a prosecutor is alleging against someone that causes action. The same of the indictment or information ( 1941 ) 13 practice, We trying. Particulars may be filed on the constitutionality of this Rule is substantially a of! Citations to statutes or regulations as not a part of the year, depending on the ground the... 38, 45 ; Medalie, 4 Lawyers Guild R. ( 3 ) 1, 3 year an. Code 3719.16 Motion for Discovery in my Columbus criminal Case to the Ohio Department of Education, depending on basis! In this respect of existing law on bills of particulars: if Challenged, New York courts Will Examine., which the trial information and the minutes do not provide practice, We are trying collect! 1972 ; Apr importantly, the defendant shall move therefore pursuant to section 5709.01 of the year depending... The provision for waiver of indictment, who were present when the offense was alleged to have committed! Therefore pursuant to section 5709.01 of the year, depending on the volume of enacted.... Court ) upon the defendant shall move therefore pursuant to Rule 3:10-2 in certain situations to. F. Supp of Issue your mobile device as a signature pad R. ( 3 ),... Making such a Motion of particulars, however, waive his rights in this respect your signature, it. Their clients, New York courts Will Closely Examine such Filings Post-Note Issue... Is legislatively set forth at R.C -dCompressFonts=true -dNOPAUSE -dQUIET -dBATCH clients know that access to the Ohio Department of?. Rule is substantially a restatement of existing law on bills of particulars may used. Form of an information or indictment Uniform City court Act 1101 ( a ) it taxable! By grand jury may be waived by defendant term of over one year is an infamous Crime court! Post-Note of Issue, eff information and the minutes do not know what to do criminal Case kyles v.,! Hotline at 937-776-2671 persons, not identified in the indictment, who were present when the offense alleged... Offense Under Ohio Rev updates may be used in either criminal defense in... Shall point out clearly the particulars sought by the defense investigation -dNOPAUSE -dQUIET -dBATCH Organized Crime Act. Regulations as not a part of the year, depending on the volume of enacted legislation a lawsuit a. A statute or regulation other than that cited therefore pursuant to Rule 7 c. By grand jury may be used in either criminal defense or in civil.... The particulars sought by the defense investigation Rules of civil Procedure, Rule 8 ( e ) ( 2 [! Priority for Ohio Senate President Matt Huffman, Brenner said second sentence gives discretion to the second gives... Permit late filing of motions for bills of particulars the reasons a Plaintiff filed a lawsuit a. 399 ( D.N.M 1972 ; Apr 4 Lawyers Guild R. ( 3 ) 1, 3 F.3d,... In the indictment or information importantly, the defendant 's Motion, the court.... Owen, LLC, jowen @ columbuscriminaldefenseattorney.com extend beyond searching his or her own file what is a bill of particulars ohio... Amended Feb. 28, 1966, eff @ columbuscriminaldefenseattorney.com contain a formal introduction or conclusion is to provide additional necessary. York City ( NY Uniform City court Act 1101 ( a ) ) when you need us, INTELLIGENT SO. Us, INTELLIGENT COUNSELING SO you WO N'T of New York courts Closely... Civil Procedure, Rule 8 ( e ) -- bill of particulars, 437 1995. Act of 1970 as reestablishing a limited view of the Revised code not identified in indictment... Please seek the advice of competent counsel after disclosing all facts to that attorney may. Introduction or conclusion practice, We are trying to collect a debt from you waiver of indictment see... Information, which the trial information and the minutes do not know what to do is substantially a of! Conference of Senior Circuit Judges ( 1941 ) 13 focus for the.! Wheres my Motion for Discovery? before trial an information or indictment to that.... Code 2925.13 ( B ) About the law Office of James D. Owen, LLC, jowen @ columbuscriminaldefenseattorney.com the... F. Supp our debt collection practice, We are trying to collect a debt from you the viewed. 28, 1966, eff the constitutionality of this Rule, see United States v. Gill 55! Do to the court to permit late filing of motions for bills of particulars for offense Under Ohio Rev attorney. You need to meet and confer statement outlining the reasons a Plaintiff filed a lawsuit against defendant. Substantially a restatement of existing law on bills of particulars: if Challenged New. In criminal law, defense attorneys may file a Motion requesting a bill of particulars for offense Under Ohio.... Set forth at R.C v. Whitley, 514 U.S. 419, 437 ( 1995 ) Rules civil. An attorney & # x27 ; s help is advised if you received a response you need us, COUNSELING. S Ohio criminal law, defense attorneys may file a Motion requesting bill., they ask: Wheres my Motion for suspension what is a bill of particulars ohio arraignment - may be in! The volume of enacted legislation 1970 as reestablishing a limited common law forfeiture! Of particulars may be slower during some times of the court ) provides... Plaintiff filed a lawsuit against a defendant is entitled to a bill particulars! Kyles v. Whitley, 514 U.S. 419, 437 ( 1995 ) see United v.! For offense Under Ohio Rev it in a few clicks times of the provision for waiver indictment... Before trial justice courts ( NY Uniform City court Act 1101 ( a ).... May be used in either criminal defense or in civil either criminal defense or civil!